Contents
When it comes to property ownership in Australia, not all titles are created equal. One lesser-known but legally intriguing method of ownership is Company Title Property. Unlike the more commonly recognised Strata Title system where you hold a direct interest in your unit and land, Company Title involves purchasing shares in a company that owns the property. This article takes a deep dive into company title property, exploring its ownership structure, legal framework, pros and cons, and important considerations for both buyers and sellers.
What is Company Title Property?
Company Title property represents a distinct form of real estate ownership. In this arrangement, a company owns the entire property, and individual investors acquire shares that correlate with a specific unit or asset, such as a car park. In other words, rather than holding a freehold title over your unit, you receive a share certificate that grants you the right to occupy a designated part of the building. This system is markedly different from Strata Title, where each owner enjoys direct title over their unit alongside shared responsibility for common elements.
This alternative ownership model offers unique advantages and challenges, stemming largely from its inherent structure and regulatory framework. To fully grasp its implications, it’s important to understand how the ownership is structured and what legislation applies.
Ownership Structure and Legal Framework
The Role of the Company
In a Company Title scenario, the entire property – including land and building – is held by a single company. Instead of owning the property directly, shareholders invest in the company, which in turn provides them with the right to occupy a specific unit. Your interest in the property is therefore reflected by your shareholding rather than a deed or freehold title.
This indirect method of ownership means that the rules, rights, and responsibilities of each shareholder are dictated by the company’s constitution rather than by a statutory framework built specifically for property owners.
Governing Legislation
Unlike Strata Title schemes – which in New South Wales, for example, are governed by the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW) – Company Title properties do not benefit from a comprehensive, dedicated statutory regime. Instead, they are primarily controlled by the company’s own constitution and regulated under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).
This means that much of the day-to-day management, sale and transfer of shares, and resolution of disputes rests on internal company rules rather than on a uniform legislative code. For those interested in the nuances of company formation and registration, our article on Quick Tips on Registering a Company in Australia can provide useful insights.
Governance and Management in Company Title Properties
The backbone of a Company Title property is its governance structure. The company’s board of directors is entrusted with managing the property, enforcing house rules, and handling financial matters. Their powers and responsibilities are outlined in the company’s constitution – a document that is central to the operation of the property.
Due to the indirect form of interest that shareholders hold, decisions regarding maintenance, regulation of common areas, and even the approval of share transfers are subject to board oversight. As a result, individual shareholders have limited control over their unit compared to a Strata Title owner. This limitation calls for enhanced cooperation and clear internal policies among co-owners.
Pros and Cons of Company Title Property
Advantages
- Flexibility: Company Title properties often allow for more flexible and customised management arrangements. The company’s constitution can be tailored to address unique needs or preference, offering an element of adaptability not always available in Strata Title schemes.
- Customisation: Owners can negotiate specific rules regarding the use of common property and operational procedures, which may lead to a more personalised living environment.
- Potential Cost Advantages: If the company is managed efficiently, the overheads and maintenance costs can sometimes be lower compared to more heavily regulated structures.
Disadvantages
- Complexity: The legal and operational framework behind Company Title properties is often more complex and less standardised, which can lead to misunderstandings or disputes among shareholders.
- Limited Autonomy: Because you are buying shares in a company rather than a freehold title, you have limited direct control over your unit and any alterations to how the property is managed.
- Transfer Restrictions: The transfer of shares is commonly subject to restrictions stipulated by the company’s constitution. Any sale may require board approval, potentially complicating or delaying the process.
- Governance Challenges: Disputes can be more likely in environments where decisions are made collectively by a board that may not always represent the interests of every shareholder equally.
Buying and Selling Company Title Properties
Deciding to buy a Company Title property is a significant decision that requires careful due diligence. Because you are not purchasing the property directly, but rather acquiring a share in a company, the process differs markedly from buying a Strata Title unit.
Considerations During Purchase
- Review the Constitution: The company’s constitution is perhaps the most critical document you will encounter. It outlines the rights, obligations, and restrictions applicable to your shareholding. Ensure that you understand any clauses regarding the transfer of shares, voting rights, and overall management.
- Examine Share Restrictions: Often, there may be restrictions on selling your shares, which could limit your options if you need to exit the investment. It is essential to consider these limitations alongside your long-term plans.
- Seek Independent Legal Advice: Given the complexity of the arrangements, consulting a legal professional who specialises in property and corporate law is advisable.
Selling Shares in a Company Title Property
Selling your interest in a Company Title property is not as straightforward as selling a freehold unit. Since the value is intrinsically linked to your shareholding, potential buyers must be informed and willing to accept the same governing structure and any associated restrictions.
The sale process typically involves obtaining approvals from the board of directors as stipulated by the company’s constitution. This requirement can sometimes elongate the selling process and may affect marketability.
Legal Considerations and Dispute Resolution
Ownership through Company Title is governed by both common commercial law principles and the specific requirements of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Directors and shareholders alike must adhere to a range of legal obligations, including directors’ duties, the maintenance of proper records, and compliance with corporate governance standards.
In the absence of a statutory framework similar to that governing Strata Title properties, disputes can sometimes arise from differing interpretations of the company’s constitution. Issues may range from disagreements over management decisions to challenges regarding share transfers.
Dispute resolution mechanisms are typically outlined within the company’s constitution and can include mediation, arbitration, or, in extreme cases, litigation. It is vital for potential buyers or current shareholders to understand these mechanisms before committing to a purchase.
Comparison with Strata Title
One of the most important aspects to consider when evaluating Company Title property is its contrast with the more traditional Strata Title system. Under a Strata Title structure, each owner holds a direct freehold interest in their unit as well as a share of common property. This direct ownership model offers a higher degree of control over one’s property and is supported by tailored legislative frameworks, such as the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015.
By contrast, Company Title ownership means that you are essentially an investor in a company, with your rights and responsibilities mediated by the company’s rules. This can result in a less straightforward ownership experience, particularly if the company is poorly managed or if there is significant internal discord.
Practical Considerations for Buyers and Owners
Before purchasing a Company Title property, it is crucial to weigh the pros and cons carefully. Ask yourself:
- Do the long-term benefits of a potentially more flexible or cost-effective management structure outweigh the risks associated with limited control?
- Have you thoroughly reviewed the company’s constitution to understand all the restrictions and obligations that come with your shareholding?
- Are you prepared to accept a governance model where decisions are made by a board of directors, potentially compromising individual preferences?
It is also important to consider the financial viability of such an investment. The market for Company Title properties can be more niche, potentially affecting liquidity and resale value. Consulting with professionals who are experienced in both property law and corporate governance can help you navigate these waters more effectively.
Maintaining Company Title Property
Once you have acquired a share in a Company Title property, effective management becomes paramount. Ongoing maintenance, upgrading common areas, and ensuring that rules and regulations remain relevant are all tasks that fall under the umbrella of the company’s board of directors.
An effective maintenance strategy can help preserve the value of the property and reduce the likelihood of disputes among shareholders. Regular meetings, transparent communication, and a clear set of guidelines are essential. In some cases, owners may wish to compare these ongoing obligations with their options under other ownership models to determine which best meets their needs.
Final Thoughts
Company Title property offers an alternative route to property ownership that diverges significantly from conventional models like Strata Title. While it can provide unique benefits – particularly in the realms of flexibility and customisation – it also introduces additional layers of complexity and potential challenges, such as restricted control over your unit and potential hurdles in the transfer process.
Before committing to a purchase, it is essential that you perform thorough due diligence. This includes a meticulous review of the company’s constitution, a clear understanding of your rights and obligations as a shareholder, and a willingness to adopt a more collective approach to property management. If the advantages align with your investment strategy and lifestyle, Company Title property could prove to be a rewarding option.
Key Takeaways
- Company Title property involves purchasing shares in a company that owns the entire property, rather than obtaining a direct freehold title.
- The ownership and management of these properties are governed primarily by the company’s constitution and the Corporations Act 2001, rather than specific property legislation.
- This structure offers advantages such as increased flexibility and the ability to customize management practices, but it also comes with disadvantages such as restricted shareholder control and potential complexities in transferring shares.
- When buying or selling Company Title property, careful review of the company’s governing documents and obtaining independent legal advice are crucial steps.
- Understanding the differences between Company Title and Strata Title is essential, as each comes with its own set of legal obligations and practical considerations.
If you would like a consultation on Company Title property, you can reach us at 1800 730 617 or team@sprintlaw.com.au for a free, no-obligations chat.
Meet some of our Business Set Up Lawyers
Get in touch now!
We'll get back to you within 1 business day.
Book in a free consultation with us to discuss your legal needs.