Contents
When you’re building a business in Australia, sharing ownership or seeking outside investment is often part of the growth journey. But how do you make sure that existing shareholders don’t lose their stake – or their say – if new shares are issued? Enter pre-emptive rights (sometimes called pre-emption rights or preemption rights). For many companies, understanding and using these rights isn’t just good governance, it’s crucial for avoiding major disputes and protecting everyone’s interests.
If you’re a founder, director, or shareholder (or planning to become one), this guide will walk you through exactly what pre-emptive rights are, how they work, why they matter for Australian businesses, and what steps you need to take to get them right from day one. We’ll cover what you need to put in place, common pitfalls, and how to use pre-emption to balance company growth with shareholder protection. If you want to grow your company without losing control – or putting relationships at risk – keep reading.
What Are Pre-Emptive Rights?
Let’s start with the basics: What are pre-emptive rights?
In simple terms, pre-emptive rights give existing shareholders the first opportunity to purchase new shares in a company before those shares are offered to external investors. This means if the company wants to raise more capital by issuing new equity, shareholders have a chance to maintain their percentage ownership and protect their influence over the company.
These rights are sometimes called pre-emption rights or simply pre-emption. No matter the terminology, they all refer to the same core concept of giving existing shareholders a “first refusal” on any new shares. This mechanism is often built into a company’s Shareholders Agreement or its company constitution. It’s a safeguard against dilution and unwanted outsiders gaining a stake in the business.
For example, if you’re one of three co-founders and the company needs more money, pre-emptive rights mean you can “top up” your shareholding before any new investors come on board. If you choose not to, only then can those new shares be offered to others.
Why Are Pre-Emptive Rights Important For Australian Companies?
Pre-emptive rights are more than just legal jargon – they have real commercial significance, especially for startups and private companies looking to scale. Here’s why:
- Protecting Ownership and Control: Without pre-emption, existing shareholders can see their ownership diluted as new shares are issued – sometimes losing majority control altogether.
- Reducing Disputes Between Shareholders: Clearly defined pre-emptive rights reduce the risk of misunderstandings about share issues and prevent conflict about who gets to buy new shares.
- Encouraging Investor Confidence: Clear, fair share allocation policies make your company more attractive to savvy investors who want transparency and equity protection.
- Complying with the Law: In some cases, offering shares pro-rata to existing shareholders is built into the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), unless your company’s constitution says otherwise.
- Simplifying Capital Raising: Having these rules already set out makes raising capital faster and smoother, as everyone knows where they stand from the outset.
Whether you’re a founder focused on long-term vision, or an early investor looking to protect your outlay, pre-emptive rights give peace of mind as your company grows.
How Do Pre-Emptive Rights Work in Practice?
Let’s break down what typically happens when a company with pre-emptive rights issues new shares:
- Notice to Shareholders: The company sends a formal notice to all relevant existing shareholders outlining the details of the new share issue – including price, timing, and number of shares available.
- First Offer Period: Shareholders have a set period (often 14-30 days, but this may vary) to decide if they want to buy all or part of their pro-rata allocation – you can choose to buy your share, part of your share, or pass altogether.
- Right of Refusal/The Next Round: If any shares are left over after existing shareholders are given their first option, those remaining shares may be offered pro-rata again to shareholders who want more (sometimes called “oversubscription rights”). If there are still shares left, only then are these shares offered to external investors or new shareholders under the terms originally proposed.
- Formal Acceptance and Payment: Shareholders confirm in writing (usually by completing a form or agreement), and arrange payment for their new shares. Once the process is complete, the company updates its share register and issues new share certificates as needed.
All the rules and processes for pre-emptive rights should be set out in either your Shareholders Agreement, your company constitution, or both. If you don’t have them, it’s time to get these critical documents in place.
Are Pre-Emptive Rights Mandatory in Australia?
This is a common question for founders and startup teams: Is pre-emption required by law?
For Australian proprietary companies (the typical “Pty Ltd” structure), the short answer is: pre-emptive rights are not always mandatory, but they are the default unless opted out.
Specifically, under the Corporations Act 2001 (Section 254D), new shares must be offered to existing shareholders before anyone else unless:
- The company constitution says otherwise (i.e., disapplies or modifies statutory pre-emption), or
- A Shareholders Agreement replaces or alters these rules.
So, unless your governing documents say something different, the law assumes pre-emptive rights will apply. However, many startups choose to customise these rules in their own Shareholders Agreement to fit their circumstances – for example, by waiving certain rights to allow for more flexible fundraising.
If you’re setting up your company structure now, it’s essential that you review your constitution and shareholders agreement so the approach to share issues is clear and aligns with your business strategy.
How Do I Put Pre-Emptive Rights in Place?
The best way to make sure your company has effective pre-emptive rights is through your Shareholders Agreement and company constitution. Here’s how to get it right:
- Draft (or Review) Your Shareholders Agreement: This legal contract between shareholders spells out exactly how new shares are offered, what happens if a shareholder wants to sell, and any exceptions to the rules.
- Include Details in Your Company Constitution: If you have a constitution, make sure it aligns with your shareholders agreement. The constitution is a public legal document lodged with ASIC and governs how your company runs.
- Check For Consistency with the Corporations Act: Ensure your documents don’t accidentally contradict Australian law. Most well-prepared agreements will clarify if statutory pre-emption is replaced with custom procedures.
- Consult Legal Experts: A commercial lawyer can help draft or review your documents to make sure your pre-emptive rights are effective and enforceable, and don’t create confusion down the track. Getting a legal review early can save a lot of time and money later.
Remember, a handshake agreement isn’t enough. Having these arrangements in writing is essential for certainty, legal compliance, and long-term business growth.
Common Pitfalls and Issues With Pre-Emptive Rights
While pre-emptive rights offer huge advantages, there are some common mistakes and challenges that can arise:
- Outdated or Poorly Drafted Documents: If your shareholders agreement or constitution is unclear, you may run into trouble when raising new capital. Shares could be issued in a way that triggers shareholder disputes or even legal action.
- Not Following the Right Procedure: Failing to give proper notice, or not observing agreed timelines, can give unhappy shareholders strong grounds to challenge the process.
- Accidentally Disapplying Pre-Emption: If your governing documents are silent or conflict, you may end up accidentally waiving key rights – so check that everything aligns.
- No Pre-Emptive Rights At All: It’s surprisingly common for new companies to start without any clear rules, which leaves both founders and early investors vulnerable in future funding rounds.
- Confusion in Sale Versus Issue: Remember that pre-emptive rights usually apply to the issue of new shares, not the transfer or sale of existing shares between parties. You may want separate rules (drag-along, tag-along, or first right of refusal) for when shareholders want to exit or sell up.
A review of your documents, ideally before raising capital, is the best way to stay safe. If you’re unsure what applies in your company, a legal health check can clarify your position and help fix any gaps.
What Legal Documents Do I Need For Pre-Emptive Rights?
To make pre-emptive rights work smoothly in your company, it’s important to have certain key legal documents up-to-date and tailored to your business. Here’s what to consider:
- Shareholders Agreement: Clearly sets out how pre-emptive rights work, including what happens with new share issues, deadlines for responses, and what happens if shareholders don’t want to buy more shares. Learn more about Shareholders Agreements.
- Company Constitution: May include or exclude the statutory pre-emption rights in the Corporations Act. Ensures that the default legal approach fits your business strategy.
- Board Resolutions: When new shares are to be issued, documenting the board’s decision properly (including steps to notify shareholders and record who accepts their rights) is vital.
- Offer Letters or Notices: Written communication to shareholders about the details of any new share issue – timing, price, quantity, and purchasing instructions.
- Share Application Forms: For shareholders who exercise their rights, a formal application ensures everything is compliant and recorded properly.
- Minutes of Meetings and Share Register Updates: Once shares have been offered, taken up, and issued, update your official company records for full compliance.
Having these documents professionally drafted (or reviewed) makes sure you’re not missing any steps and that your company’s rules can actually be enforced if a dispute arises.
Do Pre-Emptive Rights Ever NOT Apply?
Pre-emptive rights are a default but can be waived under certain circumstances. For example:
- If the shareholders all unanimously agree (often by passing a special resolution or signing a waiver) to allow a share issue without activating the pre-emption rights.
- If your constitution or shareholders agreement expressly excludes pre-emption, or narrowly defines when those rights activate (e.g., only for certain classes of shares).
- If the capital raising involves special circumstances, such as issuing shares to employees under an employee share scheme, or to a strategic investor under a pre-negotiated deal. (These arrangements should still be clearly documented to avoid confusion!)
The ability to exclude or customise pre-emptive rights is one reason it’s so important to get legal advice before your first capital raise or major shareholder change.
How Do Pre-Emptive Rights Fit With Other Shareholder and Investor Protections?
Pre-emptive rights are just one of several mechanisms that help manage risk and protect people’s interests in a growing company. Others you might consider include:
- First Right of Refusal: This often applies to the sale of existing shares, not the issue of new shares. It requires outgoing shareholders to offer their shares to other existing members first.
- Tag-Along and Drag-Along Rights: These are specially designed for circumstances where a major shareholder sells their stake. Tag-along allows minority shareholders to “tag” their shares along for sale; drag-along enables a majority to “drag” minority holders into a collective sale for better terms.
- Vesting Provisions: Especially in startups, vesting ties share ownership to continued employment or performance. This prevents early leavers from walking away with large stakes.
- Share Classes and Rights: You can create different classes of shares – some with voting rights, some only for investors – which further manages control and capital raising flexibility.
All these rights and protections work together – so it’s critical to tailor your rules to your business, your team, and your growth plans. Our guide to Shareholders Agreements and Company Constitutions has more on this topic.
Key Takeaways
- Pre-emptive rights protect existing shareholders by giving them the first opportunity to buy new shares before outsiders, reducing unwanted dilution and preserving influence.
- In Australia, pre-emption rights are the default under the Corporations Act unless varied by your company constitution or shareholders agreement.
- Setting out clear, tailored rules for pre-emptive rights in your shareholders agreement and/or constitution helps avoid disputes and makes capital raising smoother.
- Common mistakes include not having proper documents in place, not following agreed procedures, or accidentally waiving important protections – review your agreements early.
- Pre-emptive rights should be considered alongside other key shareholder protections like tag-along, drag-along, and vesting provisions for holistic risk management.
- Consulting with a specialist commercial lawyer can ensure your documents align with your business needs and current law, saving you trouble down the track.
If you’d like a consultation about pre-emptive rights or structuring your company’s shareholder arrangements, you can reach us at 1800 730 617 or team@sprintlaw.com.au for a free, no-obligations chat.
Meet Our Lawyers for Business Set Up
Get in touch now!
We'll get back to you within 1 business day.
Book in a free consultation with us to discuss your legal needs.