Contents
Attracting and retaining top talent is a challenge every Australian business faces, whether you’re a small startup or an established company. You might have heard about Employee Share Schemes (ESS) as a way to motivate and reward your team, but you’re not quite sure how they work or if they’re right for your business.
In recent years, ESS employment has become increasingly popular in Australia, especially among startups and innovative businesses looking to offer employees a direct stake in the company’s future success. However, setting up an Employee Share Scheme is more than just offering employees “a slice of the pie.” There are essential legal, tax, and compliance requirements you need to understand to get it right – and to make sure both you and your team benefit.
In this guide, we’ll walk you through what ESS employment involves, why you might consider it, how to properly implement a scheme, and what the key legal steps are. Whether you’re looking at launching your first “My ESS” program or just want to understand your options, we’re here to help you demystify the process and keep your business on the right side of the rules.
What Is ESS Employment?
ESS employment simply refers to the use of Employee Share Schemes – sometimes called Employee Share Plans or Employee Equity Schemes – as part of your overall employment and reward strategy. These schemes allow employees to acquire shares or options in the business, giving them an ownership interest and direct exposure to the business’s growth and value.
In plain English, an ESS is a way of letting your team “have skin in the game.” If the company does well, everyone benefits, helping align all stakeholders’ interests and boosting motivation. This is particularly attractive for startups and growing businesses that want to offer something beyond a traditional salary – and might not yet have the cash flow for big salaries or bonuses.
Why Consider an Employee Share Scheme?
- Attracting Top Talent: Competitive ESS offers can help your business stand out in a crowded market, especially when cash salary budgets are tight.
- Retaining Key Staff: Employees are more likely to stay if they have a real stake in the company’s long-term success.
- Incentivising Performance: ESS can directly link rewards to business growth or achieving specific milestones.
- Aligning Interests: Share ownership aligns staff interests with company goals, fostering a culture of ownership.
But how do you set up an ESS, and what do you need to keep in mind legally?
How Does an Employee Share Scheme Work?
An Employee Share Scheme usually involves offering current (and sometimes future) employees one of the following:
- Shares: The employee receives actual ownership in the company, just like any other shareholder.
- Share Options: The employee gets the right (at a future date) to buy shares at a set price. If the company’s value rises, the options could be worth more than they cost to purchase.
Sometimes, Employee Share Schemes are also extended to contractors or advisors – but there are specific legal requirements if you want to go down this path. Raising capital through ESS can affect your company structure and compliance obligations, so it’s important to plan properly.
What’s the Difference Between an ESS and “Sweat Equity”?
ESS often gets confused with “sweat equity.” While both reward staff with a stake in the business, sweat equity usually refers to shares or options granted in exchange for services already performed (like helping to launch a startup), rather than being an ongoing employment incentive. It’s also worth considering differences between sweat equity agreements and minimum wage obligations to ensure you’re compliant with Fair Work requirements.
Is My Business Eligible For ESS Employment?
Most Australian companies can offer an ESS, but there are some specific requirements and restrictions. Generally, eligibility depends on your company type, size, and whether the scheme meets certain “safe harbour” criteria under Australian tax law.
For example:
- Company Structure: Most ESS are offered by proprietary limited companies (Pty Ltd), but public companies can also set them up. Partnerships and sole traders generally can’t offer shares in the strict legal sense, as they don’t have share capital.
- Size Limits: Some tax concessions and exemptions only apply to companies below certain size or turnover thresholds. If you’re running a small business or startup, you may qualify for more generous tax treatment.
If you’re not sure if your business is eligible, speak with a legal expert who can assess your structure and advise on the best approach.
Planning Your Employee Share Scheme: Key Things to Consider
Before launching your ESS, it’s worth slowing down and getting clear on the details. Implementing a scheme isn’t just about promising your team a few shares – it’s a legal, financial and cultural decision that shapes your business for years to come.
- Scheme Objectives: What are you trying to achieve? Retain staff? Attract new talent? Reward performance? Clarify your goals before choosing the right structure.
- Shares vs Options: Will your team receive actual shares, or options to buy them later? Shares confer immediate ownership rights, while options can vest over time or depend on performance.
- Vesting Schedules: Will shares or options “vest” (become owned) immediately, or over a period? Vesting incentivises employees to stay and contribute, with their entitlement growing over time (for example, 25% per year for four years).
- Leaver Provisions: What happens if an employee leaves (resigns, is dismissed, or is made redundant)? Many schemes distinguish between “good leavers” and “bad leavers” – with different outcomes for shares or options.
- Valuation: You’ll need to determine the fair value of shares or options, especially if there are tax implications. This is sometimes called the “strike price” for options.
- Communication: It’s vital that employees understand how the scheme works, what the rules are, and what benefits (and risks) come with “my ESS.” Clear documentation and education are key.
Taking the time to plan all this properly will save you headaches – and potential disputes – down the track.
How Do I Set Up an Employee Share Scheme?
Setting up an ESS means more than just issuing a few shares and calling it a day. In Australia, you’ll need to follow some concrete steps to get compliant and make your scheme effective.
1. Put The Right Business Structure In Place
As mentioned earlier, only companies (not sole traders or partnerships) can offer shares or share options legally. If you’re still operating as a sole trader or partnership, consider incorporating a company before rolling out an ESS. Here’s a guide on setting up a Pty Ltd company.
2. Design The ESS Rules & Agreements
You’ll need to draft comprehensive ESS rules, which become the legal “playbook” for how the scheme works in practice. These rules should cover:
- Eligibility (who can participate)
- How grants are made (and how many shares/options are on offer)
- Vesting schedules and conditions
- How shares are valued and transferred
- What happens if a participant leaves
- Dispute resolution and company rights
Usually, each participant then signs an individual Employee Share Scheme Agreement reflecting these rules.
3. Consider Shareholders Agreements
If you have other shareholders (such as co-founders or investors), it’s crucial your ESS is consistent with your Shareholders Agreement. This avoids future conflicts over voting, dilution, and decision-making. It’s not uncommon for Shareholders Agreements to be updated alongside a new ESS rollout.
4. Address Tax and Compliance Requirements
Australian tax rules around ESS are complex. While there are tax concessions for genuine employee share schemes (especially for startups under the “Startup Concessions”), they only apply if you meet certain criteria and deadlines on reporting. You’ll also need to:
- Provide employees with detailed statements about their shares/options and potential tax consequences
- Report ESS details to the ATO annually
- Understand any Capital Gains Tax (CGT) implications for your business and your employees
Getting the tax side wrong can result in unwanted bills for you and your team, so it’s wise to get specialist advice here.
5. Communicate, Educate and Launch
Your team needs to know what “my ESS” means for them – both the opportunities and obligations. This requires clear, user-friendly communications, a Q&A process, and supporting materials. Many businesses hold information sessions or workshops so staff are confident in how the scheme works.
What Legal Documents Will I Need?
To successfully run an ESS, you’ll need a suite of legal documents to protect the business, comply with laws, and set clear expectations. Here’s a quick checklist:
- Employee Share Scheme Rules: The main document outlining how your ESS works in detail.
- Employee Share Scheme Agreement: Signed by each participant, setting out their rights and responsibilities.
- Shareholders Agreement: Governs relations between all shareholders and ensures the ESS fits into your broader business structure.
- Company Constitution: Should allow for multiple classes of shares/options, and may need amending.
- Board or Shareholder Resolutions: Approve the setup of a new ESS and future grants.
- Ongoing Reporting Documents: Templates and checklists for reporting to the ATO and communicating with employees.
- Employment Agreement: ESS terms are often referenced in your main Employment Agreements – so coordinate the wording.
It’s best to have these documents tailored to your unique circumstances, rather than relying on generic templates. Poorly drafted documents can lead to disputes or tax compliance failures down the road.
What Other Legal Requirements Do I Need to Follow?
Outside of the ESS itself, launching and running a compliant business that offers shares to employees means you need to follow a range of Australian laws:
- Corporations Act 2001 (Cth): Sets the basic legal framework for companies offering shares, including rules on share issuance, registers, and disclosure.
- ASIC Regulations: The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has rules regarding fundraising and employee share offers, especially if you’re raising capital via ESS. There may be disclosure exemptions for genuine employee schemes, but it’s important to confirm with a corporate law expert.
- Tax Law and Reporting: As mentioned earlier, make sure you meet all ATO requirements for ESS setup and annual reporting.
- Australian Consumer Law (ACL): Any claims you make about business value or share incentives must be accurate and not misleading. Learn more about your ACL obligations.
- Employment Law: Your arrangements should comply with the Fair Work Act, especially if ESS is offered in lieu of part of salary or as a bonus. Employment agreements should cover ESS participation clearly.
- Privacy Law: Handling employee data requires a suitable Privacy Policy, especially if shares or options are administered via an online platform.
- Intellectual Property Protection: Register your trade marks (such as your brand or logo) to protect the value of what your employees are investing their energy in!
How Do I Manage and Update “My ESS” Over Time?
Launching an Employee Share Scheme is just the start. Ongoing management is crucial to keep your team, ATO, and stakeholders happy. Here are some pro tips:
- Regularly review the effectiveness of your ESS, seeking staff feedback and checking that it’s achieving your original goals.
- Keep your documentation up to date – every new share or option grant should be reflected in your cap table and company records.
- Update your Shareholders Agreement or Constitution as needed if your structure or plans change.
- Educate new employees about the scheme to maximise engagement and understanding.
- Stay on top of all reporting and compliance tasks each financial year.
Compliance is ongoing, not a one-off. Failure to maintain accurate records or update your agreements can undermine the effectiveness of your ESS and potentially breach legal duties.
Key Takeaways
- Implementing an Employee Share Scheme can help your business attract, reward, and retain key staff, aligning their interests with your business’s growth and success.
- ESS employment involves more than just offering employees shares – you need the right legal structure, clear documentation, and an understanding of tax and regulatory obligations.
- Only companies can legally issue shares or share options; sole traders and partnerships need to incorporate before starting an ESS.
- You’ll need tailored agreements, a clear set of scheme rules, and consistent updates to your Shareholders Agreement and corporate records.
- Tax, corporation, privacy, employment, and consumer laws all affect ESS implementation – specialist advice is essential.
- Ongoing management, clear employee communications, and staying up to date with compliance are crucial to keep your “My ESS” running smoothly and fairly.
- Consulting with legal experts early in the process can save you from costly mistakes and unlock maximum value from your scheme.
If you would like a consultation on setting up an Employee Share Scheme or any aspect of ESS employment, you can reach us at 1800 730 617 or team@sprintlaw.com.au for a free, no-obligations chat.
Meet some of our Employment Law Lawyers
Get in touch now!
We'll get back to you within 1 business day.
Book in a free consultation with us to discuss your legal needs.