Contents
Preference shares are an increasingly popular tool for Australian companies seeking to raise capital without surrendering control. Whether you’re a business owner looking to secure additional funding or an investor seeking a stable income stream, understanding preference shares can help you make informed decisions in today’s competitive financial landscape.
What Are Preference Shares?
Preference shares are a special class of shares that offer holders priority over ordinary shareholders when it comes to dividend payments and asset distribution during liquidation. Unlike ordinary shares, preference shares typically do not come with voting rights. This feature allows companies to access additional capital while keeping decision-making power concentrated with existing shareholders.
In many cases, preference shares provide a middle ground between debt and equity financing. They can deliver a predictable return to investors through fixed dividends while enabling a company to avoid the interest costs and restrictive covenants associated with loans. For example, a growing business might issue preference shares to fund new projects while still retaining full control over its strategic direction.
The flexibility of preference shares makes them particularly attractive in Australia’s regulatory environment, where the Corporations Act 2001 provides clear guidelines on share issuance.
Types of Preference Shares
There are several types of preference shares available, each tailored to meet different financial and strategic needs. Understanding these differences is essential for both company directors and potential investors.
Convertible vs. Non-Convertible Preference Shares
Convertible Preference Shares allow shareholders to convert their preference shares into ordinary shares at predetermined times or conditions. This option provides the potential for capital appreciation if the company performs well. Investors enjoy the security of fixed dividends combined with the possibility of participating in future equity growth.
Non-Convertible Preference Shares do not carry the option of conversion. Instead, they offer a fixed return that is attractive to investors prioritising a stable income. This type is particularly suitable when the primary goal is to receive regular dividends without exposure to share price volatility.
Cumulative vs. Non-Cumulative Preference Shares
Cumulative Preference Shares accumulate unpaid dividends over time. If a dividend payment is missed in one financial period, it is carried forward and must be paid out before any dividends are given to ordinary shareholders. This feature protects investors from temporary cash flow issues within the company.
Non-Cumulative Preference Shares lack this provision; if the company misses a dividend payment, the shareholder loses that dividend forever. Investors choosing this option often weigh the trade-off between a potentially lower cost of capital and the risk of missing out on future income.
Participating vs. Non-Participating Preference Shares
Participating Preference Shares grant investors the right to participate in additional dividends if the company’s profits exceed a certain threshold. This arrangement allows holders to benefit from above-average company performance, thereby increasing their overall return on investment.
Non-Participating Preference Shares limit investors to a fixed dividend rate with no additional upside, even if the company performs exceptionally well. This type is best for conservative investors who seek predictable income.
Legal Framework and Rights
The legal underpinnings of preference shares are critical to ensuring that both companies and investors understand their rights and obligations. In Australia, share issuance is governed by the Corporations Act 2001, which sets out how shares should be issued, managed, and redeemed.
Key legal rights for preference shareholders include:
- Dividend Priority: Preference shareholders must receive their dividends before any dividend payments are made to ordinary shareholders.
- Liquidation Preference: In the event of company liquidation, preference shareholders are entitled to a return of capital before proceeds are distributed to ordinary shareholders.
- Limited Voting Rights: Typically, these shares do not grant voting rights, allowing existing management to retain control.
Ensuring that the terms of preference shares are clearly defined in the company’s constitution is crucial. This clarity can help avoid disputes later on and ensures compliance with statutory requirements. Moreover, companies must follow strict disclosure and reporting requirements. When issuing or redeeming preference shares, businesses are required to notify the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) to maintain transparency and regulatory compliance.
Benefits of Issuing Preference Shares
There are several distinct advantages to using preference shares as part of a company’s capital structure:
- Capital Raising Without Dilution: By issuing preference shares, companies can raise funds while avoiding the dilution of voting power among existing shareholders.
- Predictable Income for Investors: With fixed or cumulative dividend payments, investors gain a stable income stream, making preference shares ideal for conservative portfolios.
- Flexibility: Preference shares provide companies with alternatives to traditional debt financing, allowing them to manage their capital more flexibly and to align financing strategies with growth plans.
- Enhanced Credibility: The issuance of preference shares signals a commitment to balanced financial management and can enhance a company’s reputation with lenders and investors alike.
Furthermore, companies often use preference shares in conjunction with other instruments, such as debt or ordinary shares, to create a diversified capital structure.
Redeemable Preference Shares
Redeemable preference shares add an additional layer of flexibility to a company’s financing options. These shares are issued with a built-in provision that allows the company to repurchase them at a predetermined time or upon the occurrence of specific events.
Definition and Purpose
Definition: Redeemable preference shares are a type of preference share that the company can buy back after a specified period or once certain conditions are met. These terms are agreed upon at the time of issuance and are usually detailed in the company’s constitutional documents.
Purpose: The primary goal in issuing redeemable preference shares is to provide an exit mechanism for investors and to offer them certainty regarding the duration of their investment. For the company, this means access to capital on a temporary basis without the long-term obligations associated with permanent equity.
Such mechanisms are particularly beneficial when a company anticipates that its financial situation will improve over time, making it feasible to repurchase the shares at a later stage without straining its cash flow.
Legal Framework and Key Terms
Just like with other types of preference shares, the issuance of redeemable preference shares is regulated by the Corporations Act 2001. Key components include:
- Redemption Conditions: Clear terms must set forth when and how the shares can be redeemed. These might include a specific time period (e.g., after five years) or trigger events defined within the share terms.
- Dividend Terms: Redeemable shares typically offer fixed dividends. In many cases, these dividends are cumulative, shielding investors from missing out on payouts due to temporary underperformance.
- Voting Rights: Consistent with other preference shares, redeemable shares generally have limited or no voting rights.
- Liquidation Rights: In the event the company winds up, redeemable preference shareholders are prioritised in recouping their investment over ordinary shareholders.
Redemption Process
The process of redeeming preference shares involves several important steps:
- The shares must be fully paid-up before redemption is considered.
- Redemption terms outlined in the company’s constitutional or contractual documents must be strictly adhered to.
- The company must ensure that funds used for the redemption are sourced appropriately, often from accumulated profits or a dedicated re-financing mechanism.
This careful process not only protects the interests of shareholders but also ensures that the company remains compliant with regulatory requirements. For instance, companies must formally notify ASIC when preference shares are redeemed, reinforcing transparency in corporate dealings.
Key Legal Considerations for Preference Shares
Incorporating preference shares into your capital structure requires careful legal planning. Some of the most critical considerations include:
- Defining Terms Clearly: The rights attached to preference shares – such as dividend payment schedules, redemption rights, and liquidation preferences – must be clearly spelled out in the company’s constitution or articles of association. Ambiguities here can lead to disputes and even legal challenges later.
- Regulatory Compliance: All aspects of issuing and managing preference shares must adhere to the stipulations of the Corporations Act 2001. Non-compliance can result in penalties or complications with shareholder relations.
- Disclosure and Investor Communication: Full disclosure regarding the terms, risks, and benefits of preference shares is essential. Investors must be made aware of the nuances, such as the lack of voting rights and the implications during liquidation, to make an informed decision.
- Integration with Other Financing Instruments: Companies need to consider how preference shares interact with other parts of their capital structure – for example, balancing them against ordinary shares or debt financing – to maintain financial stability and flexibility.
Practical Implications for Companies and Investors
From a practical standpoint, preference shares offer benefits that support both corporate growth and investor security. For companies, these shares provide a method to raise substantial funds without risking operational control. At the same time, investors gain access to a financial instrument that delivers a fixed return in the form of dividends and offers greater security in the event of liquidation.
Consider a scenario where a company is preparing for major expansion. By issuing preference shares, the company can obtain the necessary funding without diluting the influence of its founders or existing majority shareholders. This setup enables the company to handle the capital requirements of growth while continuing to operate under its preferred management structure.
For investors, especially those seeking stable, long-term returns, preference shares are an attractive investment. The fixed dividend payments create a reliable income stream, and the cumulative features – if applicable – provide additional security against missed payouts. This predictability is especially valuable in volatile market conditions where ordinary shares may fluctuate significantly.
Furthermore, redeemable preference shares offer a planned exit strategy. Investors know that after a certain period, the company is obliged to repurchase the shares, thereby providing liquidity even in companies that might otherwise be considered illiquid investments. This balance of risk and return makes preference shares a uniquely appealing option in the broader context of corporate finance.
Successful integration of preference shares into your funding strategy also depends on broader business considerations. For instance, it might be useful to explore whether starting your business from home is a viable long-term option, or if infrastructural investments will require additional forms of financing. In any case, the flexibility offered by preference shares ensures that companies are better equipped to align their financial strategies with their operational goals.
Conclusion and Key Takeaways
Preference shares represent a versatile financing tool that provides significant benefits for both companies and investors. By offering fixed dividends, priority in asset distribution, and flexibility in terms of conversion and redemption, they help companies raise capital without relinquishing control and give investors a stable, predictable return.
- Definition: Preference shares provide priority in dividends and liquidations, usually without voting rights.
- Types: They come in various forms – convertible vs. non-convertible, cumulative vs. non-cumulative, and participating vs. non-participating – each with unique benefits and trade-offs.
- Legal Framework: Governed by the Corporations Act 2001, proper documentation and disclosure are crucial for compliance and transparency.
- Redeemable Feature: Redeemable preference shares offer a defined exit strategy for investors while providing companies with short-term capital.
- Strategic Benefits: Preference shares help maintain control for existing shareholders, provide predictable income for investors, and enhance overall financial flexibility.
Overall, understanding the dynamics of preference shares can help you build a robust capital structure that supports growth and minimises risk for both the company and its investors.
If you would like a consultation on preference shares, you can reach us at 1800 730 617 or team@sprintlaw.com.au for a free, no-obligations chat.
Meet some of our Getting Finance Lawyers
Get in touch now!
We'll get back to you within 1 business day.
Book in a free consultation with us to discuss your legal needs.