In Licence vs. License: Key Considerations for Managing Your Intellectual Property Rights

Contents

Intellectual property (IP) is one of the most valuable assets your business can own. Whether you operate a start‑up or an established enterprise in Australia, knowing how to manage your IP effectively is crucial to protect your innovations, brand identity, and competitive advantage. One of the most common dilemmas business owners face is deciding between granting an IP licence or executing an IP assignment. In Australian English, the noun “licence” (as used in an IP licence) differs from the verb “license” – an important distinction that, when explored, can have profound implications on your business’s control over and future revenue streams from your IP.

Understanding IP Licences: Definition and Types

An IP licence is a contractual arrangement whereby the owner of intellectual property (the licensor) grants permission to another party (the licensee) to use one or more specified IP assets without relinquishing ownership. This subtle yet fundamental approach allows you to maintain control over your creative outputs while generating an ongoing revenue stream through royalties. It’s a flexible solution tailored for business owners who want to retain ownership but also capitalise on opportunities to extend their IP’s reach.

There are several types of IP licences available, each with its own set of characteristics:

Exclusive Licence

An exclusive licence offers the licensee the sole right to use the IP in a particular area or market. In exchange, the licensor agrees not to grant the same rights to anyone else within that space and often refrains from using the IP themselves. This arrangement can add significant value to a business’s reputation and market share if the exclusive partner delivers on the promise.

Non‑Exclusive Licence

A non‑exclusive licence permits multiple parties to utilise the same IP concurrently. This type of licence is ideal for licensors looking to maximise their IP’s user base and revenue potential without limiting their own ability to exploit the asset. The licensor retains the right to continue using the IP and can grant additional licences to further boost income.

Sole Licence

A sole licence is a hybrid arrangement. Although it grants the licensee exclusive rights to use the IP in a certain territory or within specified parameters, the licensor retains the right to use the IP for their own purposes. This option can serve as a compromise for businesses that wish to delegate routine operations to a partner while continuing to leverage their IP strategically.

The benefits of an IP licence include:

Ongoing revenue generation through royalty payments
Retaining ownership and control over the IP
Flexibility to tailor usage rights to different markets or regions
Opportunities to partner with established players while keeping your asset secure

For businesses focused on protecting their intellectual property, protecting your IP with a trade mark is an important step. Maintaining robust control over your IP portfolio ensures that any licence agreement remains beneficial and mitigates potential risks.

Understanding IP Assignments: Definition and Implications

An IP assignment is a legal document that permanently transfers ownership of intellectual property rights from the assignor to the assignee. Unlike an IP licence, an assignment is irreversible. This means that once the assignment is complete, the original owner relinquishes all rights, control, and potential future revenue streams related to that IP asset.

The key characteristics and implications of an IP assignment include:

Permanence: Once you assign your intellectual property, the transfer of ownership is final. The assignee, who may be another business or an investor, gains full control and rights similar to how a tangible asset is owned and managed.
Lump Sum Payment: Rather than receiving ongoing royalty payments, an assignment typically provides a single, upfront payment. This may be beneficial if you need immediate capital or if the asset no longer aligns with your core business strategy.
Simplified Management: With the transfer of IP ownership, you avoid the administrative burden of managing licences or the risk of misuse. The new owner becomes fully responsible for the IP, including any associated liabilities or compliance requirements.

IP assignments may prove useful when an IP asset has matured beyond your strategic needs, or if you wish to mitigate risks associated with maintaining or enforcing your IP rights over an extended period. However, the permanent nature of assignments means that this decision should not be taken lightly.

Key Differences Between an IP Licence and an IP Assignment

When choosing between an IP licence and an IP assignment, it is essential to understand the fundamental differences:

Ownership Retention vs. Transfer: In an IP licence, you maintain ownership and control over your IP while allowing another party limited rights of use. In contrast, an IP assignment transfers all ownership rights, leaving you without any further claim to the asset.
Revenue Structure: Licences typically generate recurring income in the form of royalties while assignments offer a one-off lump sum payment. Your choice will depend on your financial objectives and cash flow requirements.
Flexibility and Control: With an IP licence, you can specify conditions such as duration, territory, and quality standards, thereby retaining a degree of control over your IP’s use. An assignment, however, relinquishes that flexibility completely.
Risk Management: Maintaining an IP licence allows you to monitor and manage how your IP is used, potentially reducing risks associated with misuse or infringement. Once IP rights are assigned, the new owner assumes full responsibility, and any future issues are no longer within your remit.

Legal Considerations When Choosing an IP Management Strategy

Deciding between an IP licence and an IP assignment involves careful consideration of various legal and strategic factors. It is important to conduct a thorough review of your business objectives and assess how each option aligns with your long‑term plans:

Business Strategy: Consider whether your business model benefits from ongoing revenue and market expansion through strategic partnerships. An IP licence allows you to retain this potential while keeping overall ownership intact. On the other hand, if you intend to exit a particular market segment or simply generate immediate capital, an assignment might be more appropriate.
Valuation and Financial Needs: Evaluate the monetary value of your IP. IP licences can yield steady, long‑term income, which may be appealing if your IP is integral to your ongoing business operations. Alternatively, if securing an immediate financial return is critical, the lump sum from an assignment might serve you better.
Risk Mitigation: Maintaining an IP licence offers the benefit of retaining control and oversight. This reassurance can be especially valuable if the IP is central to your competitive advantage. Conversely, an assignment removes the burden of managing the asset and the potential for future disputes, transferring those risks to the new owner.
Legal and Regulatory Compliance: Both options have their own legal obligations. When licensing your IP, you may need to ensure that the licence agreement complies with relevant statutory and contractual rules. The Australian government’s IP Australia provides guidelines on intellectual property rights and enforcement that can be useful when drafting your agreements. It’s equally important to consider how an assignment could impact any existing contracts or business arrangements. Consulting with an experienced IP lawyer can help you navigate these complex issues.

Implementing a robust review process is also vital. Regularly revisiting your agreements—whether licences or assignments—can ensure that they continue to serve your evolving business needs without exposing you to unintended liabilities. For instance, if market conditions change or if a partner is not meeting agreed standards, having the ability to review and redraft contracts can be invaluable.

Implementing IP Licences or Assignments in Your Business

Once you have decided on the appropriate method for managing your IP rights, it’s time to implement the necessary legal instruments. Here are some practical steps to follow:

Assess Your IP Assets: Begin by conducting an audit of your intellectual property. Identify the assets that could generate revenue or that play a key role in your business’s value proposition.
Define Your Objectives: Determine whether you wish to retain ownership while monetising your IP over time, or if you prefer to transfer the asset entirely for a lump sum. This decision will shape the structure of your agreement.
Draft Clear Agreements: For an IP licence, outline the scope of the rights being granted, the duration of the licence, territorial limits, royalty structures, and quality controls. If opting for an assignment, ensure that the transfer is unconditional and that all intellectual property rights are comprehensively addressed.
Consult with Experts: Engaging professionals can help you avoid costly missteps. For example, having your agreements reviewed by an experienced legal team ensures both compliance and that your interests are adequately protected. When considering your business set‑up issues, you might also want to review relevant topics such as company set up strategies that align with your overall IP management plan.
Register and Protect Your IP: Regardless of whether you opt for a licence or assignment, protecting your intellectual property is essential. This includes taking steps to register your trade mark or other relevant IP protections with the appropriate government bodies, such as IP Australia.

In some cases, your IP may be easily replicable or vulnerable to infringement. To guard against misuse, you might even choose to transfer a trade mark under strictly negotiated conditions that still afford you some ongoing benefits.

Reviewing Your Existing IP Agreements

As your business evolves, it is paramount to periodically review your IP agreements. Market conditions, technological advancements, and changes in business strategy may render your original contracts less effective over time. Regular reviews help:

Identify potential breaches or areas where the agreements no longer align with your strategic goals.
Ensure that royalty structures and financial terms remain competitive.
Allow you to negotiate amendments before a potential dispute escalates.

Engaging in a comprehensive review, such as a contract review and redraft, can help ensure that your licensing arrangements or assignment agreements continue to protect your IP and contribute to your business’s success.

Key Takeaways

An IP licence allows you to retain ownership while generating ongoing revenue through royalties.
An IP assignment results in a permanent transfer of IP ownership, typically providing a lump sum payment.
The choice between licence and assignment should depend on your long‑term business strategy, financial needs, and risk tolerance.
Ensure your agreements comply with relevant Australian regulations, with guidance available from resources like IP Australia.
Regular reviews and professional contract redrafting can safeguard your interests and adapt to evolving market conditions.

If you would like a consultation on managing your intellectual property rights – whether through an IP licence or an IP assignment – you can reach us at 1800 730 617 or team@sprintlaw.com.au for a free, no‐obligations chat.

Alex Solo

Alex is Sprintlaw’s co-founder and principal lawyer. Alex previously worked at a top-tier firm as a lawyer specialising in technology and media contracts, and founded a digital agency which he sold in 2015.

Do you need legal help?
Get in touch now!

We'll get back to you within 1 business day.