Contents
If you’ve ever considered joining a multi-level marketing (MLM) business, or you’ve been pitched an opportunity to “get in early” and make passive income from recruiting others, you’re not alone. MLMs and network marketing often position themselves as exciting business opportunities – but there’s also a lot of discussion about pyramid schemes and whether network marketing falls into that category. For small business owners and entrepreneurs in Australia, understanding the difference between MLM and pyramid scheme models is crucial for protecting both your finances and your reputation.
The distinction isn’t just an academic one – it carries serious legal implications under Australian Consumer Law. If you’re even thinking about starting, joining or promoting any kind of network marketing or direct sales model, you need to know where the line falls and how to stay compliant.
In this article, we’ll break down what MLM and pyramid schemes actually are, how to spot the difference, and what you need to do to operate legally in Australia. We’ll also answer key questions like, “Is network marketing a pyramid scheme?”, “What is a MLM scheme?”, and “How can I avoid breaching the law?” Let’s get started.
What Is an MLM Scheme?
MLM stands for multi-level marketing. It’s a business model that relies on a network of distributors to market and sell products or services. Unlike traditional retail, MLM businesses pay commissions not just on your own sales, but also on the sales of people you recruit into the business – this is where the “multi-level” term comes in.
Some of the most well-known global MLM companies include names like Amway, Herbalife, and Tupperware. Typically, MLMs encourage participants (often called “consultants,” “distributors,” or “team members”) to:
- Purchase initial stock or starter kits
- Sell products or services directly to consumers (through parties, events, or online)
- Recruit others to join the network, earning commissions or bonuses based on downline sales
On the surface, MLM schemes can look similar to traditional sales or franchise models. However, their unique structure – where recruitment and personal product purchases play a significant role in earning – means they sit in a grey area that requires careful navigation under Australian law.
What Is a Pyramid Scheme?
A pyramid scheme is an illegal business model under Australian Consumer Law. Pyramid schemes focus almost exclusively on recruiting members, who then pay a fee (or make a purchase) for the chance to recruit more people and earn money from their participation.
The defining feature of a pyramid scheme is that the emphasis is on recruitment over selling actual goods or services. These schemes almost always collapse, as it becomes mathematically impossible to recruit enough new members to sustain promised returns.
- There is little or no emphasis on real products or services
- Most of the money is made from sign-up fees or product purchases by new recruits
- Income is mainly based on bringing others into the scheme, not from legitimate sales
The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) is very clear: Pyramid schemes are illegal in Australia. Even participating in a pyramid scheme (knowingly or unknowingly) can attract hefty fines or criminal charges.
What’s the Difference Between MLM and Pyramid Scheme?
Distinguishing between a legitimate MLM and a pyramid scheme is critical. At a glance, both involve recruiting others and earning a percentage of sales. However, the difference between MLM and pyramid scheme models lies in how money is made and where recruitment fits into the picture.
Key Differences Explained
- Product Focus: MLM businesses are (legally) meant to centre around genuine products or services that are sold to end customers. Pyramid schemes, by contrast, are all about recruitment, with little focus on selling to actual consumers outside the network.
- Earnings Structure: In MLMs, you earn from the sales of real products – your own or your team’s. In a pyramid scheme, income comes from recruitment (usually, from the joining fees or required purchases of new recruits).
- Legal Standing: MLM businesses are legal if they follow the right structure and abide by consumer law. Pyramid schemes are always illegal in Australia, no matter what products they claim to offer.
- Market Sustainability: A true MLM can (at least in theory) survive on product sales alone, while a pyramid scheme inevitably fails as recruitment dries up and no more entry fees come in.
The difference is so important that it’s directly referenced in unfair business practices law in Australia and Australian Consumer Law (ACL).
Is Network Marketing a Pyramid Scheme?
A common question is, “Is network marketing a pyramid scheme?” The answer is: not all network marketing businesses are pyramid schemes, but all pyramid schemes disguise themselves as some kind of network or referral opportunity.
The line between the two depends on the real source of income and the business activity:
- If the emphasis is on selling valuable products to consumers who aren’t part of the company (even if those products are expensive), this leans towards a legitimate MLM model.
- If the focus is on incentivising recruitment, with little care for whether products are sold outside the network, red flags are raised – and authorities may classify it as a pyramid scheme.
MLMs must tread carefully, and businesses considering direct selling models should get legal advice to avoid accidental non-compliance. The risk of being mistaken for a pyramid scheme or even accidental franchising is very real.
What Laws Apply to MLMs and Pyramid Schemes in Australia?
Australian law takes a strong approach in protecting consumers and stamping out unfair business practices – including pyramid schemes. Here are the key areas to consider:
Pyramid Scheme Prohibition
Under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL), pyramid schemes are strictly illegal (per the ACCC). Promoting, participating in, or even attempting to recruit others to a scheme that fits the definition can result in severe penalties – including fines and possible imprisonment.
Sale of Goods and Services
For an MLM to be legal, it must sell real, valuable goods or services – the main focus of the business can’t be on recruitment alone. Sales to non-participant consumers (people not in the network) should make up a significant part of the business.
If your MLM model relies mostly on your recruits (and their recruits) buying stock or services, you should speak to a consumer lawyer before launching your business.
Misleading or Deceptive Conduct
Under ACL regulations, businesses must not make false claims about income potential or the ease of making money in network marketing. Overstating earnings, using deceptive testimonials, or hiding the real risks can lead to ACCC action.
If you market a business opportunity, ensure your materials comply with truth in advertising standards.
Franchising and Other Business Models
Be mindful that, in some cases, a business that starts as an MLM may need to comply with franchise law if it meets the criteria for franchising. This brings further compliance requirements and documentation.
A direct sales or network marketing model can have crossover features with franchising, distributorship, and agency agreements, so knowing where your business stands is essential.
Employment Law Considerations
If your MLM recruits are actually acting like employees (not true independent contractors), then employment law obligations may apply. You might need to provide minimum pay, superannuation, and other entitlements, so structure your contracts carefully.
How to Tell If an Opportunity Is a Pyramid Scheme?
It’s not always obvious. Many operations that claim to be MLM or “network marketing” might, in reality, be pyramid schemes in disguise. When evaluating an opportunity, ask these questions:
- Is the focus on selling genuine products, or on recruiting others? If recruitment is the main path to earning, it’s a danger sign.
- Do you make money primarily from sales to actual end consumers, or from “investment” by new members? MLMs should earn the majority of their revenue from external customers, not just internal purchases or sign-up fees.
- Are you required to buy large amounts of stock or a costly “starter kit” to participate? Excessive stock purchases, with no realistic way to sell the goods, is a pyramid indicator.
- Can you earn commissions without ever selling a real product? If yes, this points toward a pyramid scheme.
- Is the business model sustainable if there’s no more recruitment? If the answer is no, it’s very likely to be a pyramid.
If you answer “yes” to questions around recruitment focus or internal money flows, it’s time to pause and seek legal advice.
How Can I Run a Legal MLM Business in Australia?
If you’re interested in working with an MLM, or you want to start your own MLM-style business, following the law and best practices is essential for your peace of mind – and your business’s future. Here’s what you need to do:
1. Put Products and Customers First
Your business should revolve around selling quality, competitive products or services to real, external customers – not just downline participants. For example, selling wellness products, cosmetics, or homewares should be your primary activity, with commission structures based mainly on actual retail sales.
2. Avoid Overemphasising Recruitment
You can offer recruitment bonuses, but these should be secondary to product sales. Do not require excessive inventory purchases or entry fees from new distributors, as this triggers pyramid concerns.
3. Transparent, Compliant Marketing
Avoid extravagant income claims or misleading advertising. Your promotional materials and sales pitches should clearly explain average results and the true effort required.
4. Clear and Fair Contracts
Draft legally sound participant contracts and terms that explain expectations, commission plans, and termination/refund policies. These should be reviewed by a legal expert with experience in network marketing.
5. Ongoing Compliance Monitoring
Stay up to date with consumer protection law developments and regularly audit your procedures. Train distributors on compliance, advertising standards, and what is and isn’t allowed under competition law.
What Legal Documents Will I Need?
Operating a network marketing business or MLM in Australia, whether as the owner or as a participant, involves several contracts and documents to keep you compliant and protected:
- Distributor/Participant Agreement: Sets out the terms for those joining your network, including responsibilities, commission structures, and compliance with law.
- Customer Terms and Conditions: Clearly communicates the terms of sale, refunds, and dispute processes to end customers as required by the Australian Consumer Law.
- Privacy Policy: If you collect or handle any personal information, you are required by law to have a Privacy Policy explaining how you use and store customer data.
- Marketing and Recruitment Materials: Must be reviewed for compliance with advertising and consumer law requirements.
- Independent Contractor Agreements (if applicable): If you use brand ambassadors or other non-employee sales reps, a clear agreement is essential to clarify status and compliance obligations.
Not all network marketing businesses will need every contract listed above, but most will need several – and they’ll need to be tailored for network marketing. Speaking to a lawyer early helps ensure your legal foundation is solid and avoids pitfalls down the track.
What Are the Risks of Getting It Wrong?
If your network marketing business is found to be a pyramid scheme, the consequences can be severe:
- Regulatory Penalties: ACCC and state agencies can impose heavy fines or take legal action if you participate in, promote or even refer people to a pyramid scheme.
- Criminal Charges: In the most serious cases, criminal convictions are possible under the ACL.
- Reputational Harm: Even an accusation of running a pyramid scheme can damage your brand, hurt customer confidence, and drive away legitimate partners and suppliers.
- Personal Liability: Directors and key decision-makers can be personally liable if they’re found to have knowingly assisted or enabled a pyramid scheme.
Compliance is not optional, so make sure your model and paperwork can withstand scrutiny from both regulators and the market.
What About Hybrid Models and International Businesses?
Hybrid business models – mixing elements of MLM, franchising, and direct sales – are becoming more common. If you’re thinking about blending models or working with a business from overseas, remember:
- Australian law applies if you promote or operate in Australia, even if the parent company is elsewhere.
- Hybrid models may fall under multiple legal regimes, adding to compliance complexity – get local legal advice to avoid mistakes.
- “Binary” or “matrix” commission models often trigger pyramid scheme warnings – structure your compensation plan very carefully.
International MLM or network marketing companies must ensure their Australian operations comply with the ACL and do not fall foul of pyramid scheme prohibitions.
Key Takeaways
- MLM (multi-level marketing) models and pyramid schemes look similar on the surface, but only MLMs selling real products to genuine customers can operate legally in Australia.
- Pyramid schemes are strictly prohibited under the Australian Consumer Law – heavy recruitment focus, internal purchases, and lack of actual retail sales are key red flags.
- Even participating in or unknowingly promoting a pyramid scheme can lead to severe penalties.
- To run a compliant MLM or network marketing business, your income must be based on the sale of real goods, not on new member sign-ups.
- Careful legal structuring, transparent contracts, and compliance with consumer law and employment law are essential for all MLM/network marketing businesses.
- Always seek legal advice before joining, launching or promoting a network marketing opportunity to avoid risks that could threaten your business and reputation.
If you would like a consultation on starting an MLM business or avoiding pyramid scheme pitfalls, you can reach us at 1800 730 617 or team@sprintlaw.com.au for a free, no-obligations chat.
Meet some of our Regulatory Compliance Lawyers
Get in touch now!
We'll get back to you within 1 business day.
Book in a free consultation with us to discuss your legal needs.