Alex is Sprintlaw’s co-founder and principal lawyer. Alex previously worked at a top-tier firm as a lawyer specialising in technology and media contracts, and founded a digital agency which he sold in 2015.
When a co-founder stops contributing, it can feel deeply unfair if they still hold a large chunk of your startup. You might be putting in the late nights, taking the commercial risk and pitching investors, while someone who has stepped away keeps the same ownership position.
The tricky part is that founder shares are still shares. In Australia, your company usually can't just take them back because the arrangement no longer feels fair.
The good news is that you can plan for this. With the right shareholders agreement, constitution and share vesting agreement, you can set clear rules for what happens if a founder leaves, underperforms or becomes inactive.
Can A Company Take Back Founder Shares In Australia?
Sometimes, yes, but only if there's a legal right to do it and the company follows the correct process. A company can't simply cancel or confiscate a founder's shares because the other founders want them back.
In Australia, founder shares are property rights. If your co-founder owns shares in a Pty Ltd company, their rights will usually come from:
- the Corporations Act 2001
- your company's constitution, if it has one
- the replaceable rules, if your company uses them
- your shareholders agreement
- any share subscription agreement, vesting agreement or employee share scheme documents
- the company's share register and ASIC records
If those documents don't give the company, or the other shareholders, a right to buy back or transfer the shares, your options can be limited. You may need to negotiate a voluntary sale, offer a commercial price, or restructure future equity so the active team is better aligned.
There are a few common ways founder shares can be recovered or reduced:
- Share buy-back: the company buys the shares back under a share buy back arrangement, and they're usually cancelled.
- Share transfer: the leaving founder sells their shares to the remaining founders or an incoming investor under a share purchase agreement.
- Vesting or reverse vesting: unvested shares can be bought back or transferred if the founder leaves early.
- Issue of new shares: the company issues shares to active founders or investors, which can dilute the inactive founder's percentage, if the rules allow it.
Each option has different approvals, tax and commercial consequences. It's worth getting tailored advice before you act, especially if emotions are running high.
What Are Founder Share Leaver Provisions?
Founder share leaver provisions are clauses that set out what happens to a founder's shares if they leave the business. They're usually found in a shareholders agreement, and sometimes reflected in the constitution or share subscription documents.
These clauses are designed to avoid the awkward question later: what happens if someone leaves after six months but owns 30% of the company?
Leaver provisions often split departures into categories.
Good Leaver
A good leaver is usually someone who leaves in circumstances that aren't their fault, or where the departure is accepted by the board or shareholders. For example, serious illness, death, disability, redundancy from an operational role, or leaving with board approval.
A good leaver might be allowed to keep their vested shares, or sell them under a share sale agreement at fair market value. The exact treatment depends on the deal you agree upfront.
Bad Leaver
A bad leaver is usually someone who leaves in more serious circumstances. This might include fraud, serious misconduct, breach of confidentiality, breaching restraint obligations, or walking away without notice during a critical period.
Bad leaver clauses often give the company or remaining shareholders stronger rights, such as buying back shares at a discount or at the original issue price.
The wording matters. A vague clause like "if a founder stops helping, they must return their shares" can create a fight later about what "helping" means, who decides, what price applies and when the transfer must happen. Strong leaver provisions define the trigger events, the decision maker, the price, the transfer process and what happens if the departing founder refuses to sign the paperwork.
How Can Founder Shares Be Taken Back?
The right method depends on how the shares were issued and what your documents say. In practice, founder equity is usually dealt with in one of the following ways.
Reverse Vesting
Reverse vesting is common for startups. The founder receives shares upfront, but the company or other shareholders have a right to buy some shares back if the founder leaves before they have earned them over time.
For example, a founder might receive 25% of the company, with that equity vesting monthly over four years and a one year cliff. If they leave after six months, none or only a small portion may have vested, so the unvested shares can be bought back or transferred under the agreed mechanism.
This is often more attractive than waiting to issue shares later because everyone starts with clear ownership, while still protecting the company if someone exits early.
Company Buy-Back
A company buy-back means the company itself buys the shares from the founder. The shares are then usually cancelled, which can increase the percentage ownership of the remaining shareholders.
Buy-backs need to comply with the Corporations Act. Depending on the type of buy-back, this may involve director approvals, shareholder approvals, notices to shareholders and ASIC lodgements. The company also needs to make sure the buy-back doesn't materially prejudice its ability to pay creditors.
Transfer To Other Shareholders
Sometimes the cleaner option is for the departing founder to transfer shares to the remaining founders, a holding company or an incoming investor. Your shareholders agreement may include pre-emptive rights, meaning the shares must be offered to existing shareholders before anyone else.
This can be simpler than a company buy-back, but it still needs the right paperwork, board approvals and updates to the share register. You should also check whether the constitution gives directors a discretion to refuse registration of a transfer.
What If There Is No Shareholders Agreement?
If you don't have a shareholders agreement or vesting terms, taking back founder shares becomes much harder. The starting point is usually that the founder owns the shares recorded in the share register, even if they're no longer working in the business.
You may still have options, but they're more commercial than automatic. For example, you might:
- negotiate a voluntary sale of some or all of the shares
- agree a staged buy-out, where the company or other founders pay over time
- issue new shares to active founders or employees, if permitted and properly approved
- raise capital on terms that dilute all existing shareholders equally
- agree new governance rules so the inactive founder has less day to day influence
What you usually shouldn't do is try to force the issue informally. Removing a founder from their employee or contractor role doesn't automatically remove them as a shareholder or director. Similarly, changing ASIC records without a proper legal basis can create serious disputes.
If the relationship is strained, a carefully drafted settlement deed can be useful. It can deal with the share sale, resignation as director or employee, confidentiality, handover of company property, intellectual property, non-disparagement and mutual releases all in one place.
How To Draft Leaver Provisions That Work
The best time to deal with founder exits is at the start, before anyone has left and before the company is worth much. Clear drafting can feel uncomfortable, but it's much easier than negotiating during a breakdown.
Good founder leaver provisions should cover:
- Who is covered: founders, key employees, advisers or anyone receiving sweat equity.
- What counts as leaving: resignation, termination, reduced involvement, failure to meet agreed milestones, death or incapacity.
- Good leaver and bad leaver treatment: what each person keeps, what they must sell and at what price.
- Vesting schedule: how much equity vests over time, whether there's a cliff and whether vesting can accelerate on a sale of the company.
- Price and valuation: whether shares are bought back at issue price, market value, a discount or a price set by an independent valuer.
- Process: notice periods, completion dates, signing obligations and what happens if someone refuses to cooperate.
It's also worth aligning your documents. If your shareholders agreement says one thing and your constitution says another, you can end up with uncertainty. Ideally, the constitution, shareholders agreement, subscription documents and any employment or contractor agreements should work together.
For startups, it's common to combine leaver provisions with intellectual property and confidentiality obligations. If a founder is building the product, creating designs, writing code or speaking with customers, the company needs to own the business assets even if that founder later leaves.
Tax, Valuation And Process Issues To Watch
Taking back founder shares isn't just a legal drafting exercise. There can be tax, accounting and valuation consequences, especially if the company has grown in value since the shares were issued.
A few practical issues to think about include:
- Market value: if shares are transferred for less than market value, there may be tax consequences for the founder or the company.
- Employee share scheme rules: if the shares were issued under an employee share scheme, the plan rules and tax treatment need to be checked.
- Company solvency: if the company is buying back shares, directors need to consider whether the company can still pay its debts.
- Approvals: some actions need board approval, shareholder approval or specific ASIC filings.
- Investor consent: if you have raised capital, investor consent rights may limit what the company can do with founder shares.
Valuation can be especially sensitive. A departing founder may expect to be paid for the upside they helped create, while the remaining founders may feel the price should reflect the risk and work still ahead. A pre-agreed valuation formula or independent expert process can reduce the chance of a deadlock.
You should also think about timing. If you're about to raise investment, resolve founder equity issues before investors start due diligence. Unclear ownership, unsigned transfers or a former founder holding a large passive stake can slow down a raise or make investors nervous.
Key Takeaways
- A company can't simply take back founder shares in Australia because the arrangement feels unfair. There needs to be a legal right and the correct process.
- Shareholders agreements, constitutions and vesting documents are the key tools for managing what happens when a founder leaves.
- Good leaver and bad leaver clauses should be clear about triggers, price, approvals and transfer mechanics.
- If there's no agreement, you may need to negotiate a voluntary sale, settlement or restructure rather than forcing a transfer.
- Tax, valuation, ASIC filings and investor consent can all affect the best way to deal with founder shares.
If you'd like help with founder share vesting, leaver provisions, shareholders agreements or buying back founder shares, you can reach us at 1800 730 617 or team@sprintlaw.com.au for a free, no-obligations chat.
Drafted by Taylor, Sprintlaw's AI, and overseen by Alex Solo. How we write
Turn ownership into workable control rules
Which shareholder events should you document?
Percentages alone do not settle board control, reserved matters, transfers, leavers, deadlocks or exits. Those rules should be agreed before pressure arrives.








