Black FridayUp to $500 off your legals

Selected cases

Federal Court of Australia · [2026] FCA 1676

Goshawk Mining Pty Ltd v Hellyer Metals Pty Ltd, in the matter of Hellyer Metals Pty Ltd (in liq)

The creditors said the transfer needed urgent investigation and repeatedly offered to discuss funding it.

Federal Court of Australia10 Nov 2026

Plain-English explainers, not legal advice. Use the linked official source for section-level detail, and get advice for your situation.

Get legal help

Start here

Quick read

  • A business with a genuine disputed claim can still have a voice after the debtor enters liquidation.
  • Two businesses claimed they were owed money by Hellyer Metals: Goshawk Mining pursued $36.4 million over a failed mine sale, while Saxby Capital claimed $159,318.50 for...

Use this to check

  • Goshawk's $36.4 million claim and Saxby's $159,318.50 claim were disputed, but each was still capable of proof in the liquidation
  • A creditor's standing in an existing external administration is broader than the standing needed to start a winding-up application
  • The questioned transfer involved Hellyer Metals' only assets and a newly incorporated company connected with the people who appointed the liquidator

Decision snapshot

  1. What happened

    • Hellyer Metals was the holding company of a group that owned and operated the Hellyer Gold Mine in Tasmania.
    • In October 2023, it agreed to buy Goshawk Mining's Mount Cameron alluvial tin mine business for $25 million: $15 million in cash and shares valued by the parties at $10 million.
    • The sale did not settle.
    • Goshawk terminated for alleged repudiation and began Supreme Court proceedings in December 2023, claiming $36.4 million.
  2. What the court had to decide

    • The first issue was whether Goshawk and Saxby had standing to seek orders concerning the liquidation even though Hellyer Metals disputed their damages claims.
    • The Court had to interpret who is a person with a financial interest in an external administration under sections 5-30 and 90-20 of the Insolvency Practice Schedule.
  3. What the court decided

    • The Court held that both applicants had standing.
    • A disputed or unliquidated damages claim may not give a person standing to start a winding-up application, but that is a different question from participation in an existing liquidation.
    • Section 553 permits proofs for debts and claims that are present or future, certain or contingent, ascertained or sounding only in damages.

Practical impact

Practical read

  • A business with a genuine disputed claim can still have a voice after the debtor enters liquidation.
  • It should lodge a properly supported proof of debt, preserve the contract and loss evidence, monitor reports to creditors and raise specific concerns with the liquidator promptly.
  • A contingent creditor may have standing to seek Court supervision even though liability and quantum remain unresolved.
  • The case is also a reminder that an external administrator must be, and be seen to be, independent.

Practical takeaways

  • Goshawk's $36.4 million claim and Saxby's $159,318.50 claim were disputed, but each was still capable of proof in the liquidation
  • A creditor's standing in an existing external administration is broader than the standing needed to start a winding-up application
  • The questioned transfer involved Hellyer Metals' only assets and a newly incorporated company connected with the people who appointed the liquidator
  • The Court focused on the combined effect of relationships, delay, record-gathering failures, limited investigation and the later funding conflict
  • Creditors had repeatedly offered to discuss funding, but the liquidator did not meaningfully engage with those invitations

What the Court decided

The Federal Court removed the liquidator of Hellyer Metals and appointed a replacement. The two applicants had disputed damages claims, but they were still creditors with a financial interest in the existing liquidation.

The case was decided on apprehended lack of impartiality. The Court did not find actual bias, decide the creditors' contract claims or rule that the earlier asset transfer was unlawful.

How a failed mine sale led to the liquidation dispute

Goshawk agreed to sell a Tasmanian tin mine business to Hellyer Metals for $25 million. The deal did not settle, and Goshawk sued for $36.4 million. Saxby separately claimed payment for pre-IPO advisory work.

While those claims were unresolved, Hellyer Metals transferred its only assets, shares in mine-operating subsidiaries, to Celestial Group. The new company was incorporated on the transfer date and was connected with people behind Hellyer Metals. The transaction documents described consideration through assumed liabilities, but it appeared those liabilities had not been assumed.

Key points

  • 14 October 2023: the $25 million mine sale agreement was made
  • December 2023: Goshawk began its $36.4 million damages proceeding
  • 5 November 2025: Hellyer Metals' only assets were transferred to Celestial Group
  • 2 December 2025: the Supreme Court made a $36.4 million freezing order
  • 22 January 2026: Hellyer Metals entered creditors' voluntary liquidation
  • 10 November 2026: the Federal Court removed and replaced the liquidator

Why the disputed creditors had standing

Hellyer Metals disputed both applicants' claims. The liquidator argued that they were not creditors with standing to seek orders under section 90-15 of the Insolvency Practice Schedule.

The Court rejected that argument. The strict rule about a person using a genuinely disputed debt to start a winding-up application did not control participation in an existing liquidation. Because section 553 permits contingent and unliquidated damages claims to be proved, the applicants were creditors with a financial interest in the administration.

What created the appearance of a lack of independence

No single complaint explains the result. The Court assessed the relationships and conduct together. The liquidator had been appointed by people connected with the questioned transfer and retained the solicitor who introduced them. He did not move quickly to collect records or investigate the transfer, and he did not meaningfully engage with the creditors' invitations to discuss funding.

Key points

  • The liquidator did not use statutory powers to obtain all relevant company records, including Xero access
  • The investigation ledger recorded 30.35 hours to 4 May, with 12 minutes on litigation funding
  • A draft report was shown to people who could be targets of a recovery claim
  • A later funding arrangement involved interests that did not align cleanly with creditor recoveries
  • The liquidator took inconsistent positions about the freezing order protecting the transferred assets

A practical response for a business creditor

  1. Lodge the proof of debt

    Explain the legal basis, amount and supporting evidence, including any pending proceeding or counterclaim.

  2. Identify the commercial concern

    Describe the transaction, asset movement or record gap precisely instead of making a general allegation.

  3. Ask focused questions

    Request information about the investigation, preservation of records, funding and relevant deadlines in writing.

  4. Make any funding proposal concrete

    State the work that may be funded and ask what budget, indemnity, approval and independence safeguards are required.

  5. Get advice before seeking Court orders

    Standing, evidence, costs and the interests of the administration all matter. Removal is not a routine creditor remedy.

What this judgment does not establish

Key points

  • It does not establish that the November 2025 transfer was voidable
  • It does not determine the Goshawk or Saxby contract claims
  • It does not find actual bias by the removed liquidator
  • It does not let a funding creditor direct the liquidator's decisions
  • It does not make delay or disagreement alone sufficient for removal

The judgment is useful because it explains standing and shows how independence concerns can accumulate. Its application to another liquidation will depend on the evidence and the interests of that administration.

Common questions

Can a business be a creditor if its damages claim has not been decided?

Yes, for the purposes considered in this case. Section 553 of the Corporations Act allows claims that are present or future, certain or contingent, ascertained or sounding only in damages to be proved in a winding up. Goshawk and Saxby could lodge proofs and therefore had a financial interest in the external administration. That does not mean the claim is automatically admitted for its full amount or will ultimately succeed.

Did the Court decide that the share transfer was unlawful?

No. The transfer was a central reason why a prompt and independent investigation mattered, but the Court did not decide whether it was voidable or whether directors or officers had breached duties. Those questions were left for the replacement liquidator's investigation and any later proceeding.

Why was the liquidator removed?

The Court found numerous connected facts that could cause a fair-minded observer to apprehend that the liquidator might not act impartially. They included relationships around his appointment, the solicitor he retained, delays, incomplete collection of records, limited investigative work, the handling of creditor funding offers, circulation of a draft report and a later funding conflict.

Does a funding offer let a creditor control a liquidator?

No. A liquidator must retain independent control over the administration and decide what action is in creditors' interests. Creditor funding can make an investigation possible, but its terms, purpose and allocation must not compromise the liquidator's independence.

Can creditors replace a liquidator whenever they lose confidence?

No. The Court said removal is not lightly exercised and must be warranted for cause and serve the interests of the liquidation. Subjective dissatisfaction is not enough. In this case, the creditors' loss of confidence had an objective basis in the evidence.

What should a business do when a customer enters liquidation?

Lodge a proof of debt with the contract, invoices, correspondence and loss calculation. Read reports to creditors, note deadlines and identify any transaction that may affect recoveries. Put focused questions in writing. If funding, voting, examinations or Court supervision may be relevant, obtain insolvency advice early because the process and cost risks are fact-specific.

Related topics

How Sprintlaw can help

Update history

Case10 Nov 2026

Federal Court replaces liquidator after independence concerns

The Federal Court removed and replaced the liquidator of Hellyer Metals. Two businesses with disputed damages claims had standing as creditors, and the combined evidence created a reasonable apprehension that the liquidator might not act impartially.